TV personality and former judge Greg Mathis is speaking out about the high-profile federal case against music mogul Sean “Diddy” Combs — and he’s not pulling any punches.
During a recent interview, Judge Mathis shared his personal opinion on the ongoing trial, saying:
“If the trial ended today, I would give Diddy 5–10 years in state prison. Only issue — he’s not being charged with a state crime.”
Combs is facing a range of serious federal charges, including sex trafficking, racketeering, and abuse of power. Prosecutors allege the Bad Boy Records founder used his influence and resources to control and exploit multiple victims.
Explosive Testimonies and a Pattern of Abuse
Just two weeks into the trial, court proceedings have already been marked by dramatic and disturbing testimony. Witnesses — including singer Cassie Ventura, former employees, and dancers — have described private events known as “freak-offs,” alleging a toxic culture of manipulation and coercion.
One of the most talked-about pieces of evidence is a 2016 hotel surveillance video that shows Diddy assaulting Cassie. The footage was initially challenged by his legal team, who attempted to block it from being used in court. The judge denied the motion, allowing the video to remain a centerpiece in the prosecution’s case.
Prosecutors argue the incident illustrates a long-running pattern of abusive behavior — a key part of their broader racketeering and trafficking claims.
Federal vs. State Charges
Judge Mathis used his platform to raise questions about the legal system itself, pointing out the differences between state and federal prosecutions.
“This case highlights the limitations in our system,” Mathis noted, referring to the absence of state-level charges where sentencing and courtroom processes differ significantly.
Though Mathis is not involved in the trial, his public commentary echoes a growing sentiment among observers who are closely watching how the case plays out.
The Kid Cudi Incident Resurfaces
The trial has also revived shocking allegations involving rapper Kid Cudi. Prosecutors say Diddy allegedly blew up Cudi’s car in 2012 after learning he was romantically linked to Cassie. Though not part of the official federal charges, the incident was brought up in court to support the prosecution’s argument that Combs would go to extreme lengths to assert control.
Cudi even testified during the trial, adding more weight to the narrative of intimidation and retaliation.
What’s Next?
Diddy has been denied bail multiple times and remains in custody at Brooklyn’s Metropolitan Detention Center. With several weeks of testimony still ahead, new revelations continue to emerge almost daily.
As the legal battle unfolds, public attention remains firmly fixed on the courtroom — and figures like Judge Mathis aren’t holding back their assessments.
