A woman turned to Reddit for advice after a family conflict left her feeling torn between loyalty to her sister and honesty with the rest of her family.
The 27-year-old explained that she was “caught in the middle of some family drama” and wasn’t sure if she handled the situation the right way.
She shared that her oldest sister, now 33, married young at 19 to a man who was 25. “They were together for about 10 years, had 2 kids, and then had a very messy and very public divorce,” she recalled.
After the divorce, her sister began dating a 21-year-old, which caused major tension with the family. “Things blew up with the family, and she basically cut contact with all of us,” the poster said. For years, her sister skipped family gatherings and kept her distance.
More recently, the sister found love again. She got engaged, became part of a blended family with her fiancé, and is raising three children along with his older child. Originally, the couple planned a May wedding, but when she found out she was pregnant, they decided to quietly elope at the courthouse.
The poster admitted she and her sister hadn’t spoken for a while, until a rough moment at work and at home pushed her to reach out. After venting to her mother about a tough move and an unhappy job, she said her mom “just tore me down and made me feel worse.” That moment helped her realize why her sister had distanced herself.
She described her mother as someone who insisted on giving her opinion, but often in ways that left her children feeling unsupported. “My mom always told us growing up, she would give us her opinion whether we like it or not, she will always be truthful,” the woman wrote. “But she has a habit of just making us feel awful instead of supported.”
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(707x422:709x424):format(webp)/woman-keeps-sister-secret-elopement-and-pregnancy-090325-01-cc3b5f5e30904cf28890876888f86119.jpg)
This new understanding encouraged her to reconnect with her sister. When they spoke, her sister confided in her about the elopement and pregnancy, asking her not to share it with anyone else.
The woman kept the secret, but when the news finally became public, the family was shocked. “I didn’t lie when they asked me,” she explained. “I admitted that my sister FaceTimed me this morning and told me, but I said it wasn’t my place to share.” She also chose not to reveal the pregnancy, saying, “Again, not my story to tell.”
Her decision upset her mother and middle sister, who both felt betrayed. “My middle sister and my mom were mad that I kept it from them. Things ended awkwardly,” she said. Later, her middle sister told her that their mother was very hurt, even saying, “Well I guess I’m just the villain.”
Now, the woman is wondering if she made the right choice. “On one hand, I feel like I honored my sister’s trust and did the right thing,” she said. “On the other, my mom and middle sister clearly feel betrayed, and now there’s more tension in the family.”
Reddit users were quick to defend her. Many praised her for respecting her sister’s privacy. One commenter wrote, “You knew this wasn’t your story to tell, and you rightly believed that your sister should be the one to share her own life events, on her own terms.”
Another user reassured her: “You honored your sister’s trust — that’s the right call. Family curiosity doesn’t trump someone else’s privacy, especially with sensitive stuff like pregnancy and elopement.”
Although her mother and middle sister may feel upset, commenters agreed that she acted responsibly. As one person put it, “Your mom and middle sister can be upset all they want, but that doesn’t make you wrong.”
In the end, the woman didn’t solve the family conflict, but she did protect her sister’s trust — and for many, that was the right choice.
